Get your CMS Part B Program Transmittals Here!

Click Here for your web-only discount!

Ambulatory Coding & Payment Report  
ED Coding Alert
Family Practice Coding Alert
General Surgery Coding Alert
Medicare Compliance Week
Medicare Legislation & Regulation
Medical Office Billing and Collection Alert
Neurology Coding Alert
Neurosurgery Coding Alert
Ob-Gyn Coding Alert
Oncology Coding Alert
Ophthalmology Coding Alert
Orthopedic Coding Alert
Otolaryngology Coding Alert
Pathology/Lab Coding Alert
Pain Management Coding Alert  
Pulmonology Coding Alert
Radiology Coding Alert
Urology Coding Alert
For More Specialities
Part B Insider
Medical Newswire

Audio Conferences
Audio Tapes
Audio CD's
Print Transcripts

Search Back Issues Now!
Current subscribers can log-in and access their newsletters anytime.




P4P May Lead To A Transfer From Some Specialties To Others
Some specialty groups may lend themselves more to quality guidelines


Pay for performance may well be inevitable in 2007 and 2008 -- but will it save Medicare any money?

It's hard to predict, say experts. It doesn't help that we can't agree on a definition of quality, let alone whether quality leads to lower costs, notes attorney Rebecca Burke with Powers, Pyles Sutter & Verville in Washington. The easiest parts of quality to define, such as information technology, may be the ones that lead to the least savings.

Some physician groups fear that P4P will mean a net transfer of funds from some specialties to others. Some specialties have developed more detailed quality standards than others, and some one-size-fits-all quality standards may make certain groups look better than others.

For example, neurosugery isn't tailor-made for quality-based reimbursement, says Pat Boudreaux, data specialist with Tyler Neurosurgical Associates in Tyler, TX. "We deal a lot of the time with critically ill patients," who may stay in the hospital forever no matter how good the doctor's care is. Tyler Neurosurgical has had one or two experiences with managed care plans' P4P programs, and "It just doesn't feel like we're ever going to get a fair share" because of the high degree of morbidity in the patient population, says Boudreaux.

"Our statistics are going to compare pretty shabbily," especially with specialties such as internal medicine, says Boudreaux. Other specialties, such as orthopedics or critical care, are likewise badly suited to P4P, notes Boudreaux. "It's disastrous. We do a lot with people with brain hemorrhages," she notes. "They're either going got stay a while or they're going to die."